BRIAN WILSON’s ‘SMiLE’ vs. THE BEACH BOYS’ ‘The Smile Sessions’ | Consequence of Sound

Ten years later, Dean Essner speculates which one’s the real deal.

BY ON SEPTEMBER 27, 2014, 6:25AM

Brian Wilson's SMiLE

How do you write a follow-up to Pet Sounds? Such was the dilemma of The Beach Boys architect Brian Wilson, who, at the time, was getting pulled in a variety of musical directions.

First, there was his experimental ambitions, fueled by a consistent diet of hallucinogenics as well as his partnership with composer and lyricist Van Dyke Parks that began in 1966. There was also the loud, disapproving choir of bandmates, fans and record company executives clamoring for the simple pop music days of yore. He’d eventually fail to satisfy both, and put out nothing. But before the stress and frustration of the various influencing voices in his life became too much to take, Wilson worked on SMiLE: a psychedelic rock collage of disjointed Americana– from the prairies to the tropics to the cities and then back again.

Brian Wilson collageHe famously scrapped the project in 1967, but some of its fundamental pieces would come out in drips and drabs on various Beach Boys releases: “Cabin Essence” thrown in the middle of the otherwise uneven 20/20, “Wind Chimes” in wispy, stripped-down form on the haphazardly compiled Smiley Smile. Even album centerpiece “Surf’s Up” got a whole record named after it. These small bits of insight would only further the mystery.

In 2004, Wilson went back into the studio with Parks and a new band to rerecord his masterpiece, allowing for the album’s initially-intended arc to finally come to realization. Upon the 10th anniversary of that record – titled Brian Wilson Presents SMiLE – we provide our own deconstruction, compiling a list of pros and cons in reference to the original Beach Boys demos (which finally saw a proper release in 2011) as well as the album’s overall folklore. And, of course, there’s the following overarching question: Does the 2004 release do justice to SMiLE’s legend or should the record have just remained a series of enigmatic scraps?

Pro – The “Surf’s Up” suite in its full form for the first time:

“Surf’s Up” is one of Brian Wilson’s finest and (most melancholy) achievements, a multipart symphony of sorts about leaving behind one’s nostalgic past. In the case of his band, that past is centered on writing songs about young love and frivolous beach play, making the title a brilliant, unsettling double entendre. As good as the song is as a standalone achievement as it exists on the 1971 album Surf’s Up, though, it needs its whole conceptual arc, which includes the tracks “Wonderful”, “Song For Children”, and “Child Is The Father Of The Man”. These set the tone for what’s to come with “Surf’s Up”, showcasing the song’s melody for the first time and slowly building tension.

Pro – The solidification of the album’s theme:

As aforementioned, SMiLE is a trek through America and its vastly diverse landscapes and essences: breezy, tropical Hawaii on “Roll Plymouth Rock”; rural farmlands on “Barnyard”; the quiet, tranquil forest on “Wind Chimes”; and the chaotic hustle of the city on “Mrs. O’ Leary’s Cow”. In individual form, each song vividly signifies one place. But on Brian Wilson Presents SMiLE, each stray location suddenly becomes a special part of a larger whole.

Pro – Van Dyke Parks finally gets his due

Van Dyke Parks

Much of SMiLE’s detailed, intricate storyline can be attributed to Van Dyke Parks, who conceptualized the project with Wilson and wrote a large portion of the album’s lyrics. But it took a long time for people to realize that. Even if you’re a Beach Boys purist and don’t believe that Brian Wilson Presents SMiLE should exist in the first place (without the help of his bandmates), then you should at least feel good for Parks. One can only imagine how draining the original 1966 sessions were, and it’s nice to know that all the work he put in finally amounted to something.

Con – Superfluous lyrics:

2011’s The Smile Sessions suggested an album largely unfinished, however some of the instrumental passages that lacked lyrics, I’d argue, were perfect as is. On Wilson’s 2004 version, in an attempt at filling up some of these empty spaces, Parks penned new words and I’m not sure all of them are necessary. For instance, on The Smile Sessions, “Holidays” (on Wilson’s edition it’s “On A Holiday”) has no vocals at all, allowing for the track’s wind instruments and marimbas to gorgeously swell at the front of the mix. But on Brian Wilson Presents SMiLE, Wilson sings a forgettable line about pirates, cluttering up the otherwise simple, feathery melody.

Con – It needs the Boys:

If I were pressed to pick my favorite moment on The Smile Sessions, it’d be the final movement to “Cabin Essence”, where the strings, harpsichord, and bass harmonica begin to furiously swirl and Mike Love sings that immortal line of bizarre yet harrowing psychobabble that he notoriously hated: “Over and over/ The crow cries/ Uncover the cornfield.” We still get that moment on Wilson’s 2004 version, but there’s less anger and befuddlement in his voice. Part of the appeal of The Smile Sessions is it showcases the beautiful, half-completed product above the bubbling-over, in-band turmoil below the surface. And the music is better for that juxtaposition. There may have been fighting amongst the Boys, but sometimes the best art is born out of such natural tension.

Con – The end of music’s greatest folklore


Before 2004, it was a tradition amongst Beach Boys fans to re-imagine your own ordering for SMiLE using the tracks that had already been released. But Wilson’s record renders that practice useless. There was a time when SMiLE was like a book that had been incinerated in a fire, with only stray pages or lines here and there surviving the flames. In essence, because it never made it to the public, it belonged to the public. It was a blank canvas that required everyone’s imagination to come to life. Therefore, it’s hard not consider Brian Wilson Presents SMiLE, as the album to officially end the legend, a letdown in some way.

via Brian Wilson’s SMiLE vs. The Beach Boys’ The Smile Sessions | Consequence of Sound.

A further comprehensive review of The Beach Boys’ “The Smile Sessions”/”SMiLE” can be viewed at the following link:


A review of the 2001 CD reissue of “Smiley Smile” featuring “Wild Honey” can be viewed at the following link:

Smile Smile

About Cosmic Dwellings

'Cosmic Dwellings' is a social media network consisting of a fine mix of retro rock and pop music, a radio drama production, an ebook serial and several works of poetry and lyrical prose.
This entry was posted in Album, Blues, CD, Classical, Folk, Instrumental, Jazz, mp3, Music, Pop, Rhythm and Blues, Rock, Soul and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.